Images

Use mouse wheel to zoom in/out, click and drag to pan.
2 spp
4 spp
8 spp
16 spp
32 spp
64 spp
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
Color Buffers
RelMSE Heatmap
1: Input
2: G-buffers
3: P-buffers
4: Both buffers w/o Guidance
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
6: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
7: Reference
InputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)Reference
1: G-buffers
2: P-buffers
3: Both buffers w/o Guidance
4: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)
5: Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
G-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)

Charts

Relative improvement, obtained by dividing the filtered error by the input error. For each method, we show, from left to right, the improvement at 2, 4, 8, 16, 32 and 64 samples. Lower values are better.
RelMSE

Error Metrics

RelMSE
SPPInputG-buffersP-buffersBoth buffers w/o GuidanceBoth buffers w/ Guidance (Ours)Both buffers w/ Guidance (Ours, 50% capacity)
2 spp1.0000.062010.063490.059390.049490.04979
4 spp1.0000.040280.036700.039170.030710.03144
8 spp1.0000.027570.024030.027230.021130.02155
16 spp1.0000.019900.016570.019610.015660.01593
32 spp1.0000.016910.012020.015350.012390.01294
64 spp1.0000.014970.0092800.012150.0096960.01031